It’s never too cold for ice cream, especially if it’s from Cold Stone Creamery. Have you ever wondered which flavor is the most popular? In honor of Valentine’s Day, the ice cream chain revealed which flavors received the most love in 2020.

According to online ordering data, the top 10 ice cream flavors are:

  1. Cake Batter
  2. Chocolate
  3. French Vanilla
  4. Sweet Cream
  5. Cheesecake
  6. Coffee
  7. Strawberry
  8. Mint
  9. Classic Cookie Dough
  10. Cotton Candy

It doesn’t have to be your birthday to celebrate with Birthday Cake Remix which tops the list of Cold Stone Creamery’s signature creations, followed by Chocolate Devotion, Peanut Butter Cup Perfection and Coffee Lovers Only. As far as mix-ins go, brownies reigned supreme, followed closely by OREO cookies, cookie dough, caramel and fudge. Cookies & Creamery took the first spot for ice cream cakes with Tall, Dark & Delicious coming in second place.

“We know there are all kinds of love – familial, friendship, romantic, self-love… And to celebrate all that love, we’re sharing a list of most-loved ice cream flavors with our guests this Valentine’s Day,” said Sara Schmillen, vice president of marketing at Kahala Brands™, parent company of Cold Stone Creamery. “No matter what type of love you’re celebrating this Valentine’s Day, we hope to continue bringing people together over our sweet treats.”

Cold Stone Creamery is asking fans what their favorite flavor is. Head over to their Instagram page and leave them a comment.